What is the Role of the Legislative Leaders (Speakers, Majority Leaders) in the States and Congress?

The new crop and the incumbant Congress members are electing their leadership (House: Ds elected Jeffries,* Senate: 12/1) and in New York State will re-elect current leaders in the Assembly, Carl Heastie and in the Senate Andrea Stewart-Cousins.

The leadership race in the Senate is contentious, the “voters” are the members, actually the members of the majority party.  In the Senate the 56 Democrats, unless the rules are changed, by secret ballot in a closed meeting. Two candidates: Sen Schumer (NY) and Sen Von Hollen (Maryland)

Some voters have publicly announced their preferences.

The legislative leaders are akin to coaches of a team: they “coach the team and call the plays.”

Carl Heastie, the Speaker of the NYS Assembly was interviewed on Brian Lehrer’s radio program .  Heastie has an overwhelming majority: 110 Democratic members and 40 Republican members. The Republicans are spectators.

Heastie is the gatekeeper, decides committee assignments, decides which bills come to the floor, and will never bring a bill to the floor that requires Republican votes.

On Brian Lehrer’s program,  a listener asked,

Phyllis: Hi. Thank you. Will this be the year when we finally get the New York Health Act passed?  Is this the year that you will support and make sure that this bill sees life?

Brian Lehrer: Phyllis, thank you very much.

Speaker Heastie: Thank you. Thank you, Phyllis.

Brian Lehrer: Speaker Heastie, just so everybody knows what that means, it would be pretty much a state-level single-payer health system. Go ahead.

Speaker Heastie: Right. We are supportive of it. Listen, I think that we should have universal health care in this nation. We’re the only industrialized nation in the world that doesn’t have universal health care. I will say this. The municipal unions are still very opposed to the New York Health Act, so I still think we have some more working on [crosstalk]–

Brian Lehrer: That’s because they tend to have good private health insurance plans through their union jobs.

Speaker Heastie: Right. They collectively bargain their health benefits. For us in the Assembly, we give a lot of deference to unions. We’re one of the most unionized states in the country. We’d like unions to be supportive of things like this. The municipal unions are not in support.

New York State has 1.2 million unionized public employees and is a huge constituency and support the Democratic candidates with endorsements and “boots on the ground.”

Before every session in the Assembly the buzzer sounds, “conference,” the democratic caucus, as Heastie described, “… to get the temperature of the delegation.”

The route of a bill: from a member to a committee, maybe with cosponsors, the committee chair may schedule a hearing, the bill may be discussed in conference, amendments may be offered, ultimately the speaker can bring the bill to floor, which guarantees a positive vote, or simply bury the bill.  Freshman legislators usually get one bill: an unwritten courtesy.

The Assembly website allows you to read the actual bill and track the process through the legislative process.

One of my interests is middle income housing,I live in Mitchell-Lama cooperative, in the fifties and sixties the state built over 100,000 units of both rental and cooperative housing under the Mitchell-Lama* law. I had an idea on a pathway to renewing the construction of M-L housing. I worked with a legislator, we wrote and introduced a bill On my trips to Albany meetings I met with legislative staffers, met with the state housing commissioner, my idea floated around, apparently Bloomberg had another idea, he prevailed. Guess Mike has a little more clout.

At the federal level, in the House, 435 members, the newly elected House, now 256 Democrats, 218 needed to pass legislation, the Speaker assigns committees, the state delegations work together, and leadership has “whips,” usually senior members who “encourage/urge” members to vote the party line. The members almost always support their leadership.

Bills are assigned to committees and the committee chairs can schedule the bill for hearings, “markups,” the process of considering amendments and moving the bill towards the floor, with an overwhelming majority the democrats will pass bills at leadership discretion.

The expected Dem leadership.

The Speaker-elect, Hakeem Jefffries is planning on a busy first hundred days,


Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries, who is in line to become House speaker … said the Democrats will be united “right out of the gate” on reinstating Affordable Care Act tax breaks, reversing Republican Medicaid cuts, holding votes against the Iran war and undoing President Donald Trump’s tariff regime.

The Senate, 100 members, has different rules, the six year terms means you’re not continually campaigning and fund-raising.

The Senate majority leader also assigns committees and controls the flow of legislation. Senate rules require 60 votes to bring a bill to the floor, called cloture. With 56 Democrats in the Senate the Dems only require four Republican votes for cloture: eleven Republican seats will be on the 2028 ballot: will they be more bipartisan?

While leadership is the manager of his/her party’s team, in the Senate, clearly there are divisions.


There is a tension with the Dems: progressives, led by Bernie, and moderates, led by Schumer

A member can introduce a bill supporting the participation of trans athletes in women’s sports, the leader can decide not to bring the bill to the floor, a “woke” agenda will divide the electorate.

Some progressive members want to impeach Trump, others Secretary of War Hegseth, a majority in the House, 2/3 in the Senate, remember “impeach” means to indict, the Senate tries the impeachment and requires a 2/3 vote, with 56 Democrats, would 11 Republicans join the Democrats?

The constitution states,

The President, Vice President and all civil Officers of the United States, shall be removed from Office on Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery, or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors.

Read a detailed discussion of the impeachment process here.

Alexander Hamilton in Federalist Paper # 65 wrote,

A well-constituted court for the trial of impeachments is an object not more to be desired than difficult to be obtained in a government wholly elective. The subjects of its jurisdiction are those offenses which proceed from the misconduct of public men, or, in other words, from the abuse or violation of some public trust. They are of a nature which may with peculiar propriety be denominated POLITICAL, as they relate chiefly to injuries done immediately to the society itself. The prosecution of them, for this reason, will seldom fail to agitate the passions of the whole community, and to divide it into parties more or less friendly or inimical to the accused. In many cases it will connect itself with the pre-existing factions, and will enlist all their animosities, partialities, influence, and interest on one side or on the other; and in such cases there will always be the greatest danger that the decision will be regulated more by the comparative strength of parties, than by the real demonstrations of innocence or guilt.

Hamilton was incredibly prescient.

The 56 Dems in the Senate on December 1 will select the Majority Leader by secret ballot, and the leader will determine the path of the Senate.

Politics makes strange bedfellows and as we just learned from Jensen, visa-versa.


How about Union Maid …..https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRwr5R8T7eY


* Eleven Democrats did not vote, seven DSA members, two newly elected from NYC listing a number of disagreements with Jeffries, including his support for Israel, his district is 14th largest nationally in Jewish population
* Sen Mitchell and Assembly member Lama were the sponsors of the bill

Published by Peter Goodman

Former high school teacher, union thug, adjunct college instructor, school supporter staff anew Visions for Public Schools, staff for member of NYS Board of Regents

Leave a Reply